
Tote bag vs. carryall vs. holdall: differences, advantages, and how to choose
Looking for the perfect bag but torn between a tote bag, cabas, and carryall? That's understandable: at first glance, these three styles look alike. But they don't have the same structure, use, or look. This comparison will help you understand the real differences and choose the bag that fits your daily life — work, shopping, travel, the beach, or classes.
What are a tote bag, a cabas, and a carryall? Definitions
Before comparing them, let's clarify the terms. These three bags are often confused, but each has its own identity:
- Tote bag: a soft canvas or cotton bag with two long handles and no closure or lining. A flat, minimalist shape. The word "tote" comes from the English to tote = to carry. It's the simplest and lightest of the three.
- Cabas: a structured bag, often lined, with reinforcement at the base and handles. It usually has a closure (zipper or snap button) and interior pockets. More rigid than a tote bag, it stands upright on its own.
- Carryall: a large-capacity bag, soft and unconstrained by shape. Roomier than a tote bag, less structured than a cabas. Its name says it all: put in whatever you want, without worrying about organization.
The full comparison: tote bag vs cabas vs carryall
Here's the full comparison table to help you choose at a glance:
| Criterion | Tote bag | Carryall | Catchall |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | Soft, flat | Rigid, reinforced | Soft, roomy |
| Closure | None (open) | Zipper or snap button | Variable (often open) |
| Weight | Ultralight (100-200 g) | Medium (300-600 g) | Light to medium (200-400 g) |
| Capacity | 10-15 L | 15-25 L | 20-35 L |
| Pockets | None or 1 | 2 to 4 pockets | 0 to 2 pockets |
| Stands upright | No | Yes | No |
| Foldable | Yes (fits in a pocket) | No | Partially |
| Typical materials | Cotton, linen, lightweight canvas | Leather, heavyweight canvas, quilted cotton | Washed canvas, canvas, linen |
| Price range | 10-40 € | 30-120 € | 20-70 € |
| Style | Casual, minimalist | Chic, urban | Relaxed, bohemian |
The tote bag: the minimalist essential
Origins and philosophy
The tote bag originated in the early 20th century as a simple utility bag in American supermarkets. Since the 2010s, it has become a symbol of minimalism and mindful consumption. Its soft shape and two long handles make it the simplest bag there is — and that's precisely its strength.
Common materials
Cotton canvas remains the most widely used material. Durable, washable, and easy to print on, it offers surprising longevity for such a lightweight bag. Linen adds a more natural, refined touch. Hemp stands out for its strength and lower environmental impact. These plant-based fabrics are perfect for block printing, making them ideal for unique designs.
Advantages
- Featherlight: 100 to 200 g, folds up and slips into a pocket
- Ethical: reusable, durable, often made using responsible production practices
- Versatile: shopping, strolls, outings, light office use
- Customizable: patterns, embroidery, prints — it becomes an extension of your personality
- Affordable price: between €10 and €40 for a quality style
Drawbacks
- No closure: your belongings are left exposed
- Little structure: the bag sags when full
- Not suitable for heavy loads (> 3 kg)
- No pockets to keep your belongings organized
For more, check out our complete tote bag guide.
The tote: structure, elegance, and organization
What sets it apart
The tote is the chic evolution of the tote bag. More structured and often lined, it features interior pockets, a zipper, and reinforced handles. Its rectangular or trapezoidal shape gives it generous capacity without compromising its style. It stands upright, holds its shape, and makes everything inside easier to access.
Materials and finishes
Materials vary depending on the intended use: leather and suede for urban, elegant styles; heavy canvas or quilted cotton for a more relaxed feel. The quilted tote has become a must-have: soft, sturdy, and visually textured, it combines comfort and style. Reinforced cotton linings or printed fabric add a unique finishing touch.
Advantages
- Structure: stands upright and keeps its shape even when full
- Organization: interior pockets, compartments, secure closure
- Versatile: office, weekend, outings — it works everywhere
- Chic look: the shopper bag adds an instant touch of elegance
- Capacity: 15 to 25 L — laptop, notebook, pouch, bottle, sweater
Drawbacks
- Heavier than a tote bag (300 to 600 g when empty)
- Doesn't fold: takes up space even when empty
- Higher price (€30 to €120)
- More demanding care depending on the material
To help you choose, read our guide How to Choose a Women's Shopper Bag or explore our women's shopper bag collection.
Free shipping on orders over €60
The carryall: freedom and generous capacity
A no-fuss philosophy
The carryall lives up to its name: it holds everything, with no fuss. Less rigid than a shopper bag and roomier than a tote bag, it appeals with its flexibility and no-frills style. It's the bag for those who love freedom — being able to take everything along without worrying about the perfect arrangement for every item.
Its generous size (20 to 35 L) makes it an ideal companion for the market, the beach, trips, or sports activities. It squashes down in a suitcase, cleans easily, and folds up when empty.
Lively materials
Washed cotton canvas, soft linen, waxed canvas: the carryall lends itself to textured, slightly rustic materials. These fabrics soften over time and develop a patina that tells the story of the bag. Models made from high-quality canvas have a charm that industrial bags can't replicate.
Advantages
- Generous capacity: 20 to 35 L, the most spacious of the three
- Complete flexibility: adapts to the shape of its contents
- Versatile: market, beach, sports, travel, home storage
- Easy care: washable canvas, quick drying
- Affordable price: €20 to €70
Drawbacks
- No structure: the bag collapses and loses its shape
- Hard to find your things at the bottom of the bag
- Less elegant than a shopper bag in a professional setting
- Handles can sometimes be uncomfortable over long periods
For more information, check out our complete catchall guide.
Which bag for which purpose? A guide for every occasion
This is the key question. Here’s the ideal bag for your activity:
| Occasion | Best choice | Why | Alternative |
|---|---|---|---|
| Office / work | Carryall | Structure, pockets, fits a laptop | Large catchall |
| Shopping / market | Catchall | Capacity, foldable, washable | Heavy canvas tote bag |
| City stroll | Tote bag | Lightweight, discreet, practical | Small carryall |
| Beach | Catchall | Spacious, sand-resistant | Dedicated beach bag |
| Travel | Catchall or carryall | Capacity + durability | Travel bag |
| Classes / university | XXL tote bag | Lightweight, fits notebooks + laptop | Structured carryall |
| Evening out | Small carryall | Elegant, secure closure | Fabric pouch |
| Sports / yoga | Catchall | Room for your belongings | Yoga bag |
Materials and durability: choose wisely for a longer-lasting bag
The material you choose determines your bag’s lifespan, look, and care requirements.
| Material | Ideal for | Durability | Care | Look |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Organic cotton | Tote bag | Average (2-4 years) | Machine wash at 30°C | Casual, minimalist |
| Heavy canvas | Carryall, catchall | Good (4-7 years) | Machine wash at 30°C, do not tumble dry | Durable, authentic |
| Quilted cotton | Carryall | Very good (5-8 years) | Machine wash at 30°C on delicate cycle | Chic, textured |
| Linen | Tote bag, catchall | Good (3-5 years) | Machine wash at 30°C | Natural, refined |
| Leather | Carryall | Excellent (10+ years) | Nourishing balm | Luxury, urban |
| Waxed canvas | Catchall | Very good (5-8 years) | Damp sponge | Adventurous, vintage |
Care by bag type
- Cotton/linen tote bag: machine wash at 30°C, air-dry. Do not use fabric softener on block-print designs
- Quilted carryall: machine wash at 30°C on a delicate cycle, do not tumble dry. Iron on low if needed
- Leather carryall: do not wash, apply nourishing balm 2-3 times a year, store flat or stuffed with tissue paper
- Canvas catchall: machine wash at 30°C, gently brush stains. Air-dry flat
FAQ: Everything you need to know about tote bags, carryalls, and catchalls
What’s the difference between a tote bag and a carryall?
The tote bag is soft, lightweight, and has no lining or closure. The carryall is structured, lined, and has interior pockets and a closure. The tote bag prioritizes lightness, while the carryall prioritizes organization and style.
What exactly is a tote bag?
A tote bag is a simple canvas or cotton bag with two long handles and a flat shape. The word “tote” comes from the English verb “to tote,” meaning “to carry.” It’s the most minimalist bag there is: no closure, no pockets, just an open space for carrying your essentials.
Is a holdall a tote bag?
No. A holdall is larger and roomier than a tote bag. It offers more capacity (20 to 35 L compared with 10 to 15 L), making it ideal for weekends, travel or outdoor activities. A tote bag is more compact and lightweight.
Which bag is the most durable?
A quilted cotton or leather shopper will last longer than a lightweight tote bag. But durability depends above all on the quality of the construction and care. A well-made tote bag in heavyweight canvas (> 250 g/m²) can last 4 to 5 years without any problems.
Can all these bags be machine-washed?
Yes, except for leather ones. For cotton or canvas bags, opt for a cold wash (30°C) and air-dry them. Avoid tumble-drying, as it can warp the seams and shrink the fabric.
Which style should I choose for classes?
The XXL tote bag is perfect for classes: it’s lightweight and easily fits notebooks, a laptop and a pencil case. If you need more organization (pockets, compartments), choose a structured shopper.
Which bag is best for travel?
The holdall is ideal for travel thanks to its large capacity and flexible design (it folds into a suitcase). A shopper with a zip closure is also a good choice if you want a more polished look. For long trips, see our travel bag guide.
Are there ethical options?
Yes. Bokabas offers block-print cotton styles featuring exclusive patterns. Each bag is made to last, using natural materials and responsible production methods. Discover the art of block printing.
Shopper Collection
Our block-print cotton shoppers and tote bags
DISCOVER THE COLLECTIONIn a nutshell
Choosing between a tote bag, shopper and holdall is first and foremost about choosing your lifestyle. The tote bag is your understated companion for lighter days. The shopper is the perfect blend of elegance and practicality for everyday life. The holdall will follow you wherever freedom calls. And what if the real secret is switching things up depending on the occasion? A tote bag for a stroll, a shopper for the office, a holdall for the weekend — that’s the Bokabas promise: durable, colorful pieces designed for every moment in life.
Free shipping on orders over €60 · Returns within 30 days









Leave a comment
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.